The Punch Bowl is Gone

It has been a long time since I put up this chart comparing the S&P 500 index with the size of the Federal Reserve’s Balance sheet. The old adage that ” a picture is worth a thousand words” is most appropriate in this instance.


As long as the size of the Fed’s balance sheet continued to increase on account of their purchases of both US Treasuries as well as Mortgage Backed Securities, the liquidity boosted stocks inexorably higher, in spite of the fact that the underlying economic growth was mediocre at best. In other words, the seeming disconnect between what we were seeing on Wall Street and what Main Street was experiencing was most baffling to many observers. If one looked only at the stock markets, they would no doubt come away believing that this economy was one of the best in decades. That was in sharp contrast to the struggling US consumer dealing with relatively stagnant wages and rising health care costs and a employment picture that was not nearly as robust as the headline numbers coming out of DC would suggest.

However, that liquidity ( massive amounts of it) had to go somewhere and since it was not going into Main Street, it ended up going into Wall Street. After all, what else are money managers supposed to do in a near zero interest rate environment except to buy something that is going higher, regardless of whether or not the economic realities actually supported it.

Now that the liquidity that has been supporting this market is drying up, the failure of QE to actually pass through and benefit Main Street is being disclosed. Throw on top of that the similar failure of QE in both Japan and in the Eurozone to produce anything more than an “L” shaped recovery in their respective economies, and investors are getting rightfully worried. What is the next trick that the Central Banks are going to be able to pull out of their magic hat if nothing works?

Further compounding the problem has been the woes besetting the Chinese economy. Perhaps the straw that broke the camel’s back was the Fed rate hike of 25 basis points in December. Since that time, equities have moved generally lower.

My view all along has been the monetary policy can only do so much. It can perhaps prevent things from imploding but as to producing any SUSTAINED, ROBUST Growth, forget it. That requires STRUCTURAL REFORM And solid economic policy. Those of course have to make it through Congress here in the US but they first have to be endorsed or at least proposed by the executive branch. Given the current leftist occupant of the White House, that has ZERO chance of happening. In other words, I am of the view that this economy is going to remain moribund until late in 2016. Even then it might not see any solid growth depending on the results of the 2016 election in November. A Hillary Clinton presidency would spell disaster for the US economy since most believe she would merely continue the current policies that are crushing economic growth here in the US.

Fasten your seat belts – the punch bowl that has supported all this giddiness in equities is gone and now the market is going to be forced to deal with reality. None of this is going to go away anytime soon. I expect we will see rallies in equities as we move forward but I also expect that they will be viewed as selling opportunities. The mentality of “BUY the DIP” has given way to “SELL the RALLY”. Such are the ingredients of Bear markets.

9 thoughts on “The Punch Bowl is Gone

  1. Thanks Dan, great article. The “Buy the dip” frame of mind has been very strong since ’09.

    So this being the case, just from my view of TLT, it seems treasuries are resuming their rise, albeit with a little more work to do before that is confirmed.

    Would you see that as putting pressure on SJB?

  2. This is going to be a tough year. Seems to be the perfect storm for equities with China slowing and oil tumbling to new lows with no end in sight. Combined with financially inept leaders on both sides of the border will only make it worse. What a mess. Great piece, thanks Dan.

  3. Well said. The patient is having withdrawal symptoms doc… what should we do?

    Domestic and foreign policy changes are desperately needed. A total lack of leadership with the current administration.

  4. Every government is planning on massive multi-billion dollar infrastructure programs. Effectively looking for a Hail Mary pass. I doubt it will work because it’s the debt crisis that is causing this mess. I’ve yet to see a politician even acknowledge this.

    I think Rickards is correct in his assertion that this coming wave of infrastructure spending will be the trigger for a wave of inflation. We should be watching for this turning point if it happens. Perhaps this is the deflation to inflation transition that Armstrong has written about.

Leave a Reply