What’s Up with the HUI and Gold ?

“UP” it was, but the intermediate term chart is certainly not that impressive, given the pandemonium that has been taking place since the start of the New Year.


The index does seem to have carved out a bottom just above the 100 level but it must take out initial resistance near 140 and then again above the 50 period moving average to give chartists some reason to turn more solidly bullish. As things stand now, all it looks like the index has done is to bounce off a bottom and trek higher towards to the upper bounds of a sideways trading pattern. For a bullish breakout to occur, 150 will have to be cleared.

When looking at the long term chart, (monthly), the bounce occured back at the 2002 lows. Think about that for a moment! This sector had fallen to FOURTEEN YEAR LOWS.


The collapse/annihilation that began in 2012, wiped out an entire decade’s worth of gains in less than 4 years! Methinks future investors will think long and hard before tying up precious investment capital in the miners again. Perhaps this sort of horrific price action will steer more investment capital looking to diversify into gold into the gold ETF, GLD. If one is going to buy paper gold, at least the ETF does not have inept management issues to worry about.

I have said it before and will say it again, there was NO EXCUSE for any gold mining company NOT TO HAVE HEDGED expected future production when gold broke down on its price chart in early 2013 and began a bear market. Think about the huge sums of losses that could have been avoided or at the very least minimized with a solid, well thought out and properly implemented hedging program. Instead, many if not most of them, sat through a brutal bear market completely exposed to market price risk. That is why I would never tie up my own personal investment capital in one of these mining companies unless I had assurances that they had an informed, experienced risk management department which knew how to run a hedge book. Good luck finding one of those among this sorry crowd.

The reason I harp about this is because companies that deal with commodities must understand that their product experiences ups and downs in price. There is no such thing as a stagnant price. This entails an understanding of cycles. There is a time to have a bullish outlook and a time to have a bearish outlook. Grain elevator operators, exporters, cattle feeders, packers, refineries, growers, etc, all understand that part of their business involves not just producing a product but managing price risk. Without doing so, they are unnecessarily and recklessly – in my opinion – exposed to price flucutation which can seriously impact their profitability.

Why does the gold mining industry stand out as the one which refuses to join the crowd of responsible companies? The answer is simple – most miners are great at digging stuff out of the ground and presenting reasons why their product is great. What they are terrible at is recognizing that the have a fiduciary responsibilty to protect their profits. Well run companies are NOT SPECULATORS. Specs such as myself are willing to accept price risk for the sake of making profits off of movements in price. Companies are in the business of producing a product AT A PROFIT and attempting to minimize risk. You do that by locking in profitable prices when the market gives you the opportunity to do so or protecting yourself from adverse price movements with well designed hedges. Far too many of these mining companies failed to do just that. The results of this foolhardy “strategy” can be clearly seen in their abysmal share price.

Have some of them learned? Perhaps, but under pressure from uninformed shareholders, they will more than likely have learned nothing and will repeat the same mistakes the next time around. While being unhedged during a bull market in gold can accompany a soaring share price making management look like genuises, doing so requires no great skill. As a matter of fact, it requires NOTHING AT ALL. The challenge is having your company do well during times in which the price of gold is falling. THAT takes skill and knowledge of markets – something that Barrick at one time possessed but which it allowed itself to surrender under pressure from shareholders back in the mid 2000’s.

Consider that my rant for now…

Here is a quick look at the GLD holdings.

GLD and holdings

The ETF has added 7.22 tons of gold since the start of the year. That is a good sign if you are bullish the metal. It does show that there is some Western-based investment demand stirring in the metal. This is a necessary condition for gold to continue to move higher. Should this demand falter, the metal will fall lower in price again.

Lastly, some comments on the gold Commitments of Traders data out this afternoon. Remember, this data only covers through Tuesday of this week. Gold closed at $1078.40 that day. It hit a high of $1113 in today’s session before reversing lower, a climb of another $35 since Tuesday.

According to the CFTC, hedge funds covered a total of 7606 short positions in gold, including futures and options. That is a signficant amount of buying which as stated above, does not account for an additional $35 climb higher in price. Rest assured that SIGNIFICANT amounts of hedge funds shorts were covered Wednesday, Thursday and Friday this week.

Here is a chart showing the HEDGE FUND OUTRIGHT positions and comparing those to the gold price. You can see the reduction in short positions. They did add some new long positions but by comparison to the buys associated with short covering, those were outnumbered by more than a 2:1 ratio. A careful look at the associated chart shows the red line above the blue line meaning that they were still net short as of Tuesday. That may not be the case any longer with that $35 price rise since Tuesday.

hedge funds gold

Additionally, it is interesting to note the Swap Dealer positioning on gold ( as well as the Commercials).

swap dealer gold

LAstly, you can see the short covering and reduction in the net short hedge fund position to see how that short covering is pushing gold higher.

gold hedg efund

Small specs were still net short as of Tuesday. No doubt most of them are now gone as well.

gold cot charts

A quick look at the actual gold chart is in order.


Gold had a nice week to start off the New Year. It is interesting that this is exactly what it did last year to start 2015 as it rallied about $120 into the middle of last January before it began to break lower once more.

As noted in previous posts this week – as long as this financial stress and chaos remains in the markets – primarily with China – gold will remain well supported in price. As soon as the market comes to feel that the worst is over in that regard, gold is going to break lower. The question is when might that be? I wish I knew. The truth is not a single one of us know this. We just have to watch events unfold.

I should note here that when the strong payrolls number first hit the wires and were revealed to the markets, gold immediately came under strong selling pressure falling well below $1100.

Here is a 15 minute chart showing the sharp move lower that took gold down as far as $1091 minutes after the data hit the wirefeeds. Gold bulls should note this very well as it is a foretaste of what will happen to gold should the market come to believe that the worst is over as far as chaos in the Chinese/emerging markets. Gold will get hit and it will get hit hard. Do not forget that.


The reason is simple – that payrolls number caught a lot of people by surprise as most were looking for a good increase in jobs for December but mainly in the vicinity of 210,000. Instead we got a big 292,000. If that were not enough, November jobs were revised to +252K while October was revised to +307K. That in and of itself, would have fanned the flames of additional rate hikes coming from the Fed which would send the Dollar higher and by consequence, gold lower.

What the market did however, after this sharp selling reaction in gold and big move higher in the Dollar, was to focus back on the potential for further bad news out of China over the weekend, plus the fact that the wages number showed no upward pressure on wages. That brought the safe havens back into play again (Risk Aversion) with the Yen recovering from its losses along with gold and the bonds.

I only mention this to keep the readers soberminded so as not to get caught up in all the usual RA-RA that will now be coming out of the cult of gold. Gold is acting like it should be acting during a time of financial stress and chaos and uncertainty. If that goes away, gold will move lower as fears/concerns dissipate. Good traders will understand this and will therefore stay alert for any signs of stability or lessening of investor worries.

In other words, DO NOT GET MARRIED TO GOLD. It is insurance. Remember that, stay objective and be soberminded. Leave the wild-eyed gold cult to glory in its own rantings.

6 thoughts on “What’s Up with the HUI and Gold ?

  1. Love the rant TD. Question. Your other article about the yen and the bojs history of making resistance any stronger makes me wonder if that could be an issue for upside in gold… The two have correlated pretty well. Thoughts?

    • Ben;

      Happy New Year to ya….That is a very good point you raise about the yen and the price of gold. The two seem to be moving in lockstep of late. I think we can trace that to the SAFE HAVEN or risk aversion trades.

      I do not remember when it actually began, but the Yen suddenly became a safe haven currency. I do remember scratching my head at that especially when Japanese bonds were paying such mediocre interest rates and Japan was saddled with an even higher DEBT TO GDP ratio that the US. As a matter of fact, I think they still remain as one of the largest debt to GDP ratios in the world. Throw on top of that the fact that they are eerily close geographically to the nutcake in N. Korea and why anyone would view Japan as a safe haven is still beyond my ability to understand.
      That being said, for some reason the market still runs into the Yen every time we have risk aversion taking place. Some of it might be tied to carry trade unwinding as many still use the yen as a funding currency for leveraged trades.

      My thinking on the yen, if the Japanese authorities begin to make any noise about its valuation ( rest assured, the Bank of Japan is not shy and they will most assuredly let the market know their thinking if the yen moves too high for their comfort), traders will be very hesitant to fight them since the BOJ can punish speculators like no one else can who defy their will.
      I don’t think that would in and of itself derail any gold rally related to safe havens however. I think we would actually then see a delinking between the yen price and the gold price as traders look for somewhere else to park money during such times besides the yen.
      Much is going to depend at what levels the stock markets, particularly here in the US become attractive to money managers, institutions and other large speculative interests. At some point stocks get cheap in their valuation models and they will buy. When that happens, gold and the rest of the safe havens will then reverse course as RISK comes back in vogue. for now everyone is cautious as all eyes are on China.

Leave a Reply